choosemoney.co.uk
Home Credit Cards Loans Current Accounts Savings Accounts Mortgages Insurance
Credit Cards Home Low Rate Balance Transfer Reward Travel Affinity Poor Credit History Prestige Business
choose find a card


choose switch


choose browse



The myth of all-purpose plastic

By Lyndsey Burton & Jeffrey Stevens - January 2007


Why your credit card is probably not as versatile as you think

Just because a credit card is good for one thing, doesn’t mean it’s good for everything. While your credit card may score an A for its low rate on purchases, it’s probably hiding a fistful of bad grades behind its back.

And it’s these bad grades that can cost you dearly.

“There is no one single golden card that does everything well,” says Lyndsey Burton, Director of Choosemoney.co.uk.

“Most credit cards are one-trick ponies. They are great for one thing, but flunky – and in some cases disgraceful - on others. Sadly, there is often an almost deliberate attempt to trap you into paying as much interest as possible.”

We’ve identified 3 of the ‘traps’ credit card companies use to make money from those who use their credit card as an ‘all rounder’:

  • The ‘Allocation of Payments’ Trap
  • The ‘Cash Advance’ Trap
  • The ‘Use Abroad’ Trap

The 'Allocation of Payments' Trap

What is the ‘Allocation of Payments’ trap?
The allocation of payments trap is a small print condition that doesn’t allow you to pay off certain things (normally the high APR stuff) before you have paid off others (normally the low APR stuff).

So your higher rate debts (purchases, cash advances etc.) land up trapped behind your lower rate debts (transferred balances at 0%, purchases at introductory rates etc.) until the lower rate debts have been paid off in full.

And if your lower rate debt happens to be a balance transfer from another card that you’re planning to pay off over a year, it’s a long time for the higher rate debts to remain unpaid!

All credit cards have an ‘allocation of payments’ clause in their terms and conditions, which sets the order in which payments made to the account will be applied. This order states that items listed first must be fully repaid before you can begin to repay the items listed later.

Lyndsey Burton, director of personal finance website ChooseMoney.co.uk warns:

“The allocation of payments quickly becomes a minefield for anyone highly advertised (and hugely popular) credit card 0% deals – namely, because you’ve now got a very cheap and often large debt on your credit card. You have to use these cards very carefully.”

Offers to watch out for (and how they trap you)
Here are some examples of offers that could potentially see you fall into the ‘allocation of payments trap’.

  • 0% balance transfer for 12 months and 0% purchases for 3 months.


    How the trap works:
    The card entices you to transfer your current card balances to a 0% interest rate lasting for 12 months.

    This balance transfer usage alone is fine – and in fact it’s money saving! But here’s where the trap comes in: the card also entices you to spend on it by offering you 0% rates on your purchases too, for an ample 3 months.


    Sounds tempting? Unfortunately it’s not… What they don’t advertise is that you won’t be able to repay any purchases you’ve made while you’re also enjoying your 0% balance transfer deal. So anything bought on the card, from the third month onwards, will accrue interest charges and remain unpaid – effectively ‘trapped’ - until you have first repaid your balance transfer in full.


    Card companies may also offer enticing rewards to get you spending on your 0% balance transfer card. The worst culprits here are AOL credit card (by MBNA), the SonyCard credit card (by MBNA) and all the MBNA football premiership cards.

    How to avoid the trap:

    Lyndsey Burton, director of personal finance website ChooseMoney.co.uk suggests:

    “It’s all about how you use these cards. They are superb for their lengthy 0% balance transfer deals OR for spending on to enjoy the 0% introductory purchase period and various rewards on offer.


    "However, steer clear of using these cards for both transferring to and spending on during their 0% periods. Once the longest 0% period is up, the trap is removed as purchases and balances transfers usually return to the same standard interest rate – i.e. both balances are equal in cost.”

  • 0% balance transfer for 12 months and non-promotional purchase rate.


    How the trap works:
    The card entices you in with a 0% balance transfer deal, but doesn’t warn you not to spend on the card.

    The 0% balance transfer deal on its own is fine, and some cards offer really good money saving deals, allowing you to actually start repaying your credit card debts.

    However, due to the allocation of payments rule, if you spend using one of these cards your purchase transactions will effectively become trapped behind your cheaper rate balance transfer – accruing interest charges – until you’ve first repaid your balance transfer in full.

     

    How to avoid the trap:
    Lyndsey Burton, director of personal finance website ChooseMoney.co.uk suggests:

    ”If you have current outstanding credit card debts, balance transferring can save you a heap of money and can help you get back in control of your finances.

    "These cards can and should be used for 0% balance transfers. However, once your balance has been moved over, hide the card at the back of a drawer and focus on repaying your debt. Never, ever spend on it”

Offers that don’t use the trap
Fortunately, there are some cards that don’t use this trap:

  • 0% on balance transfers and purchases for 9 months.


    These cards are the only 0% cards that are suitable – allocation of payments trap-free – to use for both transferring a balance and purchase spending.

    The reason is simple; they offer simultaneous 0% interest rate deals on both balances transferred to the card and any purchases spending for the same length of time – thus removing the possibility of trapped spending debts.


    Lyndsey Burton, director of personal finance website ChooseMoney.co.uk warns:

    ”Be careful though, no 0% card is suitable for cash advances, such as drawing cash from an ATM using your card, or getting cash-back at the supermarket. This is because balances from cash transactions will always become trapped behind the 0% debts accruing rather hefty interest charges and remaining un-repayable until your 0% debt is fully repaid.”

How to avoid the allocation of payments trap

Check the introductory offer
Are the 0% deals the same length? Or does the purchase period end before the balance transfer deal?
Always read the small print
In particular, pay attention to the allocation of payment clause, which reveals the order in which payments you make are credited to your account balances.
Hide it in a drawer
As a rule of thumb, if you’re making use of a 0% balance transfer deal, hide the card away at the back of a drawer and use a more suitable card for any purchases or cash advances you may need to make.
Choose the right type of card
If you want a 0% deal for both a transferred balance and new purchases, make sure you get a card that’s suitable to do so on, e.g. the card offers a 0% rate on both balance transfers and purchases for the same length of time!
Use a good comparison website
ChooseMoney.co.uk is the only credit card comparison site that reveals which cards are suitable for balance transfers and purchase spending (eg. See here)


The 'cash advance' trap


What is the ‘Cash Advance’ trap?

Credit cards do not advertise their cash advance rate, which is more often than not considerably higher than the quoted APR (the rate charged for purchases).


Cash advances also usually carry a handling fee too, and interest is usually charged from the date of transaction – even if you repay your balance in full each month.

Be aware of the allocation of payments clause too, which usually orders payments from cheapest balance to dearest, with cash advances generally being repaid last. This can hit you especially hard if you’re enjoying any 0% balance transfers or purchases, where you may not be repaying your debt quickly.

The 'use abroad' trap


What is the ‘Use Abroad’ trap?
Most credit cards charge a ‘loading’ fee if you use the card abroad or for overseas Internet purchases.

This fee is often hidden in the small print behind a range of aliases, including a ‘foreign loading fee’, a ‘foreign transaction fee’, a ‘foreign commission fee’ or a ‘currency conversion charge’.

Most credit cards will charge a loading fee of 2.75% of the total transaction amount.

Lyndsey Burton, director of personal finance website ChooseMoney.co.uk warns:

“If you use your credit card for withdrawing cash or buying foreign currency, you can expect to be charged the foreign loading fee and the cash handling fee alongside a usually costly cash advance interest rate from the date of the transaction.”

How to avoid the ‘use abroad’ trap


Find the right card
Make sure you have a credit card that’s cheap to use abroad. Look for no foreign transaction fees and a low purchase interest rate.
Use a debit card
Use your debit card if you can, though be aware most debit cards now also charge a foreign loading fee. The Nationwide building society famously offers fee-free transactions from any ATM around the world.
Buy foreign currency or traveller’s cheques before you go
The cheapest way to buy foreign currency or traveller’s cheques in the U.K. is to withdraw the cash on your debit card from a free ATM machine (usually a bank or building society ATM – not the ones you might find in a shop or club) and then buy the foreign currency or traveller’s cheques with the cash from a competitive bureau de change, such as the Post Office.

 

Parts of this article appeared in the Daily Mirror's YourMoney section in January 2007